Thanks Lily, I hadn't considered the mechanical finger approach. I got one from Amazon and, while it took awhile to position the bad LED (and it was a bad LED, it wasn't because it was loose as I later found out), including using tape on the end of the finger assembly to get it to where I could line up the LED w/the access hole, I got it out. Put in another LED and everything's fine. Great idea on using those fingers to get it out.
Did make a post on Amazon about the LED that went bad though. I asked them for a replacement, and they responded "you're out of the 90-day warranty period" malarkey - BTW, isn't one of the benefits of LEDs that they last longer than regular bulbs? - so I gave them 1 star and wrote a comment. iJDMtoy is the manufacturer of this particular bulb, recommended by others here. Maybe I just got a bad one; the one on the other side still works.
2018 Limited (gas)
Bright white, Mocha interior
All options save Theater, S package, & vacuum delete